Another week goes by, another set of prospects get thrown into the NHL fire. On Saturday, it was Braden Holtby shutting down Toronto and receiving high praise from Don Cherry. Less than 24 hours later, Jacob Markstrom made his NHL debut in relief of Scott Clemmensen and suffered the loss. One performance was certainly way more impressive than the other, but the influence each one had on their team’s goalie situation were both massive.




Now more than ever before, I feel like a kid in a candy store. Tracking all of these prospects is a ball because I can project their increasing fantasy value with more insight and accuracy. And at this point in the season, understanding what kind of chances a prospect has to increase their role in the NHL allows you to better manage your fantasy team. The questions are mounting, the probabilities are shifting and opportunities are being dished out…yep…like candy.


To help make sense of all this, I’ve answered four “What are the chances…” questions in regards to prospects that are currently in the fantasy spotlight. These situations will surely intensify as the NHL approaches the All-Star break and then shifts gears into the playoff push. If there’s another similar question you have on another prospect, be sure to drop it in today’s Fantasy Mailbag, which is linked above.


Despite my projections, keep in mind that you never know what could happen next. The prospects below are capable of stepping up and winning big games for their club. They’re also prone to having their value regress. That could lead to a trade, a demotion or a full-time graduation. You simply have to watch as much as you can and be sure to look deeper into their situational statistics to truly get a grasp on their development pace.


What are the chances that Sergei Bobrovsky becomes the Flyers starter by next season?

Right now, Bobrovsky has a 50% chance of being the starter next season. He’ll not only have to play extremely well through the regular season, but he’ll have to continue to be consistent. He currently holds a five-game winning streak and has allowed two goals or less in each game. If he extends this kind of performance into the playoffs, he could write a similar story to that of Jonas Hiller and let a post-season run set him up to win the starting job.


In order to secure the starting role next year, he still needs to make some technique adjustments. Most importantly, he has to be bigger and taller in the butterfly. He still hunches over way too much and that kills his ability to eliminate space in the upper corners. He looks more comfortable moving in and out of certain save sequences and his rebound control is improving, but he still gives up a ton of space when he’s down in the butterfly. If he can straighten his back and crouch more at the knees than at the shoulders, it will be a major sign he’s evolving and improving.


Bobrovsky was inconsistent in December, but after an 11-day break from playing, and since Michael Leighton went down to the AHL, he has been much better. Part of this is because he’s getting consistent minutes again. That has helped revive his rhythm and boost his confidence. Every goalie goes through these highs and lows, but it’s a huge learning experience for Bobrovsky and that could keep him from losing confidence in this important stretch of games.


What are the chances that James Reimer plays for the Maple Leafs full-time next season?


Right now, Reimer has a 60% chance of making the Leafs out of training camp next year. Most of his chances rest on the shoulders of Jean-Sebastian Giguere retiring or being traded. The Leafs would also have to be confident rolling with Reimer and Jonas Gustavsson as a tandem. This doesn’t seem very plausible since they would lack a veteran presence and have one rookie and one European struggling with confidence and consistency.


With Reimer recalled for a fourth time, expect this three-goalie system to have a similar impact to the one in Philly. It will cause one or two goalies to lose their timing and rhythm and ultimately struggle. With Giguere starting tonight and then Reimer expected to start tomorrow against Tampa Bay, Gustavsson will most likely be the odd man out. But he was already struggling to begin with.


Reimer’s fourth recall is a sign that roles and plans are shifting for the Leafs, but where things go from here is totally unclear. There could be a trade in the works, they could just be waiting for the right time to send Gustavsson down for a conditioning stint, or they might just let all three goalies battle it out and display their traits for other team’s scouts.


Either way, Reimer’s value once again receives a boost. He has opened the door for a chance at a full-time gig. With the Leafs comfortable putting Ben Scrivens in a Marlies uniform, they have two solid goalies in the AHL and that also boosts Reimer’s chances of graduating to the NHL for good.


What are the chances that Braden Holtby plays for the Capitals full-time next season?


Right now, Holtby has a 40% chance of playing full-time for Washington next year. I watched him play on Saturday night and concluded that he’ll be more than ready for the NHL by the end of this season. If he gets a few more games in with the Caps, it will bring him the exposure and experience needed to make Varlamov and Neuvirth expendable. And Bruce Boudreau has already confirmed that Holtby will start again tonight against the Rangers.


I can only speculate on this, but either one of the three goalies could be traded. That’s a School of Block lesson by itself. So a lot of Holtby’s chances heading into next season depend on what Washington chooses to do with their other two goalies. They’re all under the age of 23 and they’re all tremendous talents with amazing potential. It’s a great position to be in for the Capitals, but a very tough decision on who to keep and who to possibly move.


Holtby would be fine spending another year in the AHL, just like Cory Schneider, Jonathan Bernier and many others have done in the past few years. So there’s still a 60% chance he simply spends another year carrying the workload in the AHL. This is more likely to happen, as the Capitals could let Dany Sabourin walk, thus allowing them to bring up one of Todd Ford or Jared DeMichiel from South Carolina (ECHL) to play with Holtby in Hershey.


What are the chances that Corey Crawford is Chicago’s full-time starter next season?


Crawford has a 75% chance of landing the full-time starter’s job for next year. He’s already logging “starter” minutes in Chicago and he has already played consistently enough to earn the confidence of head coach Joel Quenneville. That’s all it takes to win the job in the Windy City, as we all know Coach Q is very finicky with his goalie decisions.


A major aspect of Crawford’s success heading into next season will be his ability to continue playing with a high level of confidence. In Sunday’s game against the Flyers, he was rattled after allowing the first goal on a crazy scramble in the crease and never recovered from it. It was a clear sign that he’s still developing the mental toughness needed to be a full-time starter in a Blackhawks uniform.


Finally, his ability to put the Blackhawks in the playoffs will have the biggest impact on his role and reputation heading into next season. If he can be a huge factor in their late-season success and then win at least one playoff series, he’ll definitely improve both aspects of his career as a starter.


This is a huge stretch of games for Crawford, as success will pave the way for more opportunities heading into next year’s training camp. If he totally bombs, he’ll not only lose confidence, but some of the luster of his long-term value will fade away. But as you can see, I’m fairly confident in his ability to not only play at the same level he’s at right now, but continue to evolve and improve all areas of his game.



Write comment
Comments (10)add comment

John MacLean said:

Toronto Goalies Hi Justin, with your analysis above, where does that leave Jussi Rynnas?
January 25, 2011
Votes: +0

mike hess said:

great job As usual, up to you high standards...owning Crawford, Rinne and Hiller based on your past recommendations, a few of these are too early for me but they will be on my draft list for next season...
January 25, 2011
Votes: +0

Kris said:

... "School of Block columns sometimes seem to have little or no relevance on a site devoted primarily to fantasy hockey"

I couldn't disagree with this statement more. Solidifying goalie spots in a pool is one of, if not the, most important aspect of fantasy hockey. What Justin does on a week in week out basis is help us to better understand how to recognize the skill sets of successful goalies and his advice has done WAY more to help my fantasy teams than anything else offered up on this none!
January 25, 2011
Votes: +0

Larry said:

playoff success 3 of these teams (not the Leafs smilies/smiley.gif )would have to be considered serious contenders for the cup, playoff success would certainly cement atleast one option, especially due to the cap issues on each team.Likewise if any of the goalies fails,their team may cut bait and go in a different direction- Holtby would probably just go back to the minors for more seasoning,but the situation in Chicago and Philly is a little more urgent.
With the Leafs out of the playoffs, you would think that Burke would stop with the stop gap fixes and not bring Giguere back, and go with the 2 young goalies- or sign a younger (than Giggy) veteran for minimal salary. Giguere has no trade value now, and if he does play next year- it will be for considerably less- he has no bargaining power and the goalie market isnt showing any signs of recovery.
January 24, 2011
Votes: +0

jason said:

... Any thoughts on Dubnyk's chances of being a starter next season in Edmonton??
January 24, 2011
Votes: +1

James W said:

Goalie Dilemma hey Justin
who would you rather own in a deep keeper?

im looking for a playoff goalie which Bob is gaurunteed and Pavs not so much but in the end i want the more skilled goalie who do you think it is?
January 24, 2011
Votes: +0

Justin Goldman said:

... Ooo, that's an oversight on my behalf re: Markstrom. I'll have to add something in the School of Block forums on his game! My bad. I should have added one more "chances" question for him. Check the School of Block forums later about it. Basically, he's not NHL-ready yet and might need one more year in the AHL. But that clearly comes down to what the Panthers choose to do with Vokoun heading into the trade deadline. I wouldn't want to let him walk for nothing in free agency!
January 24, 2011
Votes: +0

Eric said:

Hockey Hoser
... Any feelings about Khubodin's chances next season?
Also totally disagree that School of Block sometimes see to have little or no relevance. With goalies being SO important fantasy hockey, where else are you getting this kind of goalie prospect analysis? Awesome job Goldman, you are my goalie guru!
January 24, 2011
Votes: +0

Kevin Cooper said:

... You mentioned Markstom made a relief appearance for Clemmensen and the impact was massive but you did not comment on it further?
January 24, 2011
Votes: +0

John H. said:

... School of Block columns sometimes seem to have little or no relevance on a site devoted primarily to fantasy hockey, but not this one. Good job!
January 24, 2011
Votes: -1
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.