Prime Cuts 2009-10


The third annual Prime Cuts roster is here! Check out the Prime Cuts rosters from 2007-08 and 2008-09. The thinking process that goes in to selecting the team is similar to Pierre McGuire’s “Monsters” for TSN (I promise that is the first and only time I will compare my thinking process to Pierre’s). Since this is a fantasy hockey site, the selection process favours players that have had strong seasons on the score sheet, obviously. However, not just goals and assists are weighted – perhaps a player has started to shoot the puck more, or play better defensively. Intangibles like heart, grit, and determination factor in to the selection process as well. It is far and away my favourite article to write each year, and I hope you will all enjoy reading it as much as I have enjoyed writing it!


Part 2 of the article series will name the second defensive pairing and third line.




Prime Cuts


The second pairing: Tyler Myers and Joni Pitkanen

The 6’8” Myers has always stood out from the crowd. Throughout his minor hockey, he towered over his peers. Due to a few significant growth spurts, he was always competing against his body, though. He constantly battled fatigue and coordination issues, and only when he reached age 16 did he really begin to figure things out. Buffalo had a good feeling about him during the summer of 2008, and they moved up in the draft to select him 12th overall. Many expected Myers to one day make the NHL as a solid top-four defenseman, but he was viewed as a project. His development since being drafted has been nothing short of spectacular, joining the likes of Shea Weber, Duncan Keith, Alex Edler, and Luke Schenn as successful graduates of Kelowna’s defence factory. He had an impressive camp this season and Buffalo decided against sending him back to the WHL. Myers let them know they made the right decision by quickly adapting to the speed of the professional game.


Among Sabre defensemen this season, he finished first in goals, assists, points, plus-minus, shooting percentage, and ice time (including the most power play time per game AND the most shorthanded minutes per game). His 48 points (including 11 goals) placed him 11th overall in the entire league, and he still hasn’t celebrated his 20th birthday yet. Myers has quickly been able to develop the skills that most average sized players struggle with – fluidity with regards to skating, stick-handing, and general awareness on the ice. The upside for Myers as a defenseman is sky high – there simply are no comparables to him. He is eons more mobile than Zdeno Chara, and he reads the game from an offensive standpoint much better as well. He is the youngest NHL defenseman to have 40 points since Bryan Berard did it back on Long Island in 1996.97. His team is 28-7-1 when he records a point. Myers was an easy choice for the 2009-10 Prime Cuts roster, just like he will be for the Calder Trophy.


Joni Pitkanen showed a glimpse of his offensive upside with the Flyers back in 2005-06, when he recorded 13 goals and 46 points in only 58 games. However, since that point he has been unable to consistently play at the level many believe he is capable of. However, he seems to have found a home as the number one guy on Carolina’s back end. His combination of size, speed, and offensive ability continue make him an enticing option for poolies, as he still has the upside to develop into a 50 or 60-point defenseman.


This season, he led the entire NHL in ice time per game, playing almost a minute more per game than Duncan Keith, who was second. He was 13th in scoring among NHL blue liners with 46 points. He also fired 161 shots on goal, more than double any other Carolina defenseman. Logging heavy minutes for a struggling team is not as impressive as doing it for a contender, but Pitkanen has played at a very high level all season. Unlike most top defensemen, he hasn’t had a stable partner, either. 20 percent of his shifts this season were with Aaron Ward, 15 percent were with Brett Carson, and nine percent were with Tim Gleason. Due to injuries, trades, and call-ups, Pitkanen was forced to adjust his game to a new partner all season long.



Prime Cuts


The third line: Steve Downie, Brandon Sutter, and Eric Fehr


Steve Downie had quite the season in 2009-10. He was the first player in almost a decade to score over 20 goals and record over 200 penalty minutes in the same season. He instantly clicked with Steve Stamkos and Marty St. Louis on Tampa Bay’s top unit, and looks to be a long-term fit there as well.


Downie has been followed by his bad boy reputation throughout his career. It’s a shame, because he has always been a very, very effective two-way hockey player. He finally was able to show it this season. He finished the season with a very impressive plus-14 rating. The next highest plus-minus number on the Lightning roster was zero. He has great hands, sees the ice well, and has the skill required by all “complementary” players – the ability to keep up with superiorly talented linemates.


His shooting percentage (19) this season is an abnormally high total, so expect a decline in goals next year (unless he decides to shoot the puck more). It was the seventh highest total in the entire league. He played less than 15 minutes per game, a number which should go up a minute or two in 2010-11. More ice time should mean more shots on goal. There are some rumors circulating that St. Louis may ask to be traded, but I don’t buy it. He is the backbone of that team. Trying to peg Downie’s upside is where things get interesting. He always has that wild streak that will make him a bit of a risk/reward type of player in fantasy hockey, but if he keeps his head on (relatively) straight, he has the skills to become a 60 or 65 point winger.


Stamkos puts it best with regards to Downie’s on-ice presence. “He creates spaces for me... everyone’s a little scared of him when he’s on the ice. He has that edge.” Well put, Steve.


Brandon Sutter’s offensive progression at the NHL has been very impressive. He scored only one goal in 50 games as a rookie in 2008-09, but followed that up with a 21 goal sophomore campaign for the Hurricanes. The most impressive part about Sutter’s season wasn’t his 21 goals, though. He recorded only two penalty minutes all season. He isn’t a perimeter player or someone who avoids tough areas or puck battles – he competes hard every game. The fact that he took one minor penalty is damn impressive (unless your league counts penalty minutes, of course). He is the perfect “ying” to Eric Staal’s “yang” down the middle in Carolina.


He should develop into a 25-30 goal, 60-70 point second-line center. He can score goals and pass the puck, and brings size and defensive acumen to the 2009-10 Prime Cuts roster.


Eric Fehr finally showed why he has been known throughout his career as a pure goal scorer. His 21 goals don’t jump off the stat sheet, but when you add some context, they should. Fehr played only 12:08 per game this season for Washington. That places him 22nd on the Capitals roster in terms of ice time per game. Out of all 20 goal scorers in the league, only Steve Downie and Jamie Benn (both at 14:42 per game) played less than 15 minutes. Fehr was able to produce very respectable numbers with essentially fourth line minutes all season long.


He played most of the time with Brendan Morrison as his center, and one of Tomas Fleischmann, Jason Chimera, or Brooks Laich on the left side. Fehr finished with 145 shots on goal. Like I mentioned with Downie earlier, more shots will come with more ice time. Fehr is a restricted free agent this summer, so it will be interesting to see what happens with him. Do the Capitals dangle him for a defenseman? In the right situation, Fehr could be a 40-goal scorer one day.


The roster (to date):



Steve Downie – Brandon Sutter – Eric Fehr

TJ Galiardi – Jay McClement – Ian Lapperiere



Tyler Myers – Joni Pitkanen

Keith Yandle – Mark Giordano



Tuukka Rask

Write comment
Comments (6)add comment

lcbtd said:

Thanks Angus! Thanks for filling my special request Angus! smilies/grin.gif

Completely forgot about Greene so good call on him.
April 21, 2010
Votes: +0

angus said:

... I really like Gunnarsson in TO. I think he was one of the better 5/6 guys this season, especially considering the brutal play of TO in their own zone all season long.

Matt Greene has become a great depth guy with the Kings - I'm a bit surprised because he was a giant pylon with the Oilers. Kudos to him for improving.
April 20, 2010
Votes: +0

lcbtd said:

Okay... Kenneth and Angus, I get all that.

I guess I'm just disappointed in not getting Angus' take on the bottom end guys who NOBODY talks about, ever.

No fantasy guides are ever useful in defining the best 3rd pairing d line or the best 3rd/4th forward line.

In a very deep keeper sim league this stuff is important so Angus' take is important because he is respected for his opinion (and deservedly so).

Okay, Angus, satiate me here - who is the best 5th/6th dmen in the league? That's all I ask. And maybe the best 3rd/4th dmen too smilies/wink.gif

Is Shane O'Brien in there? Carl Gunnerson? Hal Gill? Andy Sutton?

April 18, 2010
Votes: +0

kenneth said:

... Hey lcbtd I disagree with your statement
Those players (other than pitkanen who would of share 1st line duty w/ corvo) weren't 1st line defensemen at the beginning of the season

and most of those wouldnt even be drafted or at most mid to late rounds
April 18, 2010
Votes: +0

angus said:

... I don't think lazy is the word you are looking for - cheap, maybe. Like the Rask pick, my placement of the defensemen has a lot to do with preseason expectations.

It's not a rigorous selection process, I just am trying to reward some of my favorite players.

Cheers and thanks for the comment.
April 18, 2010
Votes: +0

lcbtd said:

Again??? Angus,

I look forward to Prime Cuts but you've disappointed again by picking a team's no.1 dman to fill your second line.

You did the same thing with your third d pairing by picking guys who aren't 5/6 guys.

Seems like a cheap way out.

Now after saying all that, you do a great job with the forwards again as you did with Part 1. I like how you pick actual depth guys to fill out your depth lines. Nice work on that! I like to read about who might be the best 4th liner in the league and who might be the best 3rd liner. Too bad I can't read who might be the best 3rd/4th dmen in the league because you took the lazy way out.

April 17, 2010
Votes: +0
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.