Fantasy Impact: The Edmonton Oilers have signed unrestricted free agent Ilya Bryzgalov to a one-year deal. The team also traded defenseman Ladislav Smid to Calgary for forward Roman Horak (swapping minor-league goaltenders Olivier Roy for Laurent Brossoit in the process).



The Oilers get: A starting goaltender who flourishes under a strong defense-first coaching system, but is dreadful under more wide-open systems. I don't think Bryzgalov will last long as a No.1, but yet the signing is a good one - because it will push Devan Dubnyk. After Dubnyk loses his hold on the No.1 job, watch him perform well in spot starts, eventually getting the No.1 job back by March. From a fantasy standpoint, neither goaltender will give strong, steady numbers because the starts will be split - with Bryzgalov getting more of them early on, while Dubnyk has them later in the campaign. Look for Bryzgalov to get his first start in an Oilers uniform November 19 against Columbus or November 21 against Florida.


As for the motivation on the Smid trade, it's obviously cap space, but why to Calgary and why for that return? Hot for Horak? I don't think so. I think Oilers scouts see something in Brossoit that they like. Remember - Brossoit played the last three-plus years in Edmonton (WHL), so scouts had plenty of exposure to him. GM Craig MacTavish understands that one of Edmonton's weaknesses is goaltending and I'm sure he and the scouting staff believe that Brossoit has a better shot at making the NHL than Roy does. 


With this trade, Brossoit assumes "Golden Boy" status. The team gave up a valuable asset to get him, which means that he will have every opportunity to succeed - more than what you typical goalie prospect gets.


See Laurent Brossoit's fantasy profile, stats and scouting report here.



See Olivier Roy's fantasy profile, stats and scouting report here.



See Roman Horak's fantasy profile, stats and scouting report here.



Fantasy Players Impacted: What little fantasy value Horak had is now gone. He's in tough to make the Edmonton lineup when they already have several players of his skill set - but better. Dubnyk's starts will take a huge hit, but the quality of his game will rise so when he does play he'll no longer hurt you as badly.


As already noted, Brossoit is now a "Golden Boy" if you are in a league that adds goalies three years before they make the NHL, then Brossoit should be at or near the top of your list.



Fantasy Players these moves help, in order


1. Bryzgalov (D'uh)

2. Brossoits 



Fantasy Players these moves hurt, in order


1. Horak

2. Dubnyk





Write comment
Comments (3)add comment

Ed. said:

... Notoriousjim, I know how you feel. I am in a league where Broissot has not only been owned for over a year, but has been offered to me as a sure-fire future star in several trade talks, dating back to the summer of 2012.
November 11, 2013
Votes: +1

Ed. said:

Players affected by Smid? Will Smid to Calgary have a meaningful impact? Slight improvement for Ramo, Berra, etc.? Fewer minutes for another D? Russell?
November 11, 2013
Votes: +0

notoriousjim said:

... sadly, i am in a league like that, and should add him
November 10, 2013
Votes: +0
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.